NHS Data – do we need a map or atlas?

Die ganze Welt in einem Kleberblat – Heinrich Bünting 1581

Building on their recent report on preparing the NHS for the “AI era“, the Tony Blair Institute have announced an effort to map the the national data architecture of the NHS. This builds on the work published last year in The Lancet Digital Health which described national data flows using publicly available data.

Personally, I love Ursula Franklin’s wonderful description that a good map is

“…meant to be useful, to assist the traveller and bridge the gap between the known and the as yet unknown”.

If this work from the TBI shows us better ways to use information to improve outcomes, reduce the burdens on staff and make our services more sustainable it will be a triumph. But still…

  • Maps are not neutral. Physical maps can reflect political and social issues more then they describe topography. The mappae mundi pictured above better presented religious concepts than geographical realities. Arguments between the Gall-Peters and Mercator projections even made it into an episode of The West Wing. Maps have implicit meanings that we need to look for and consider.
  • Maps trigger cognitive biases. What is the correct level of abstraction that makes a data map accessible, prevents readers gaining a false sense of expertise and allows the map to be created and maintained? Is there one?
  • Maps are ephemeral. The NHS doesn’t stand still. Systems, pathways, process and people are ever changing. Describing connections that exist is not the same as understanding or being able to influence / govern them. How should a data map be designed to tell us how to better cultivate what has grown, not just where to plant more systems (Margunn Aanestad sets this out much more eloquently!)

So then what does an atlas offer that a map does not? Firstly, an atlas is less bound by a singular scale and can show one region in granular detail with another in a much more zoomed out manner – not all data and data flows are created equal and understanding some in greater detail is sensible. Secondly, an atlas can layer in details making direct linkages between disconnected information. This adds richness, context and meaning. Creating and reading in this way allows us to look at information and “re-edit and piece together again without thinking we are summarising or exhausting it”. This is what drives new insights, perspectives and ideas.

This all builds on arguments better made made by Kate Crawford that for complex, critical issues, we need creative ways to better understand the social, political environmental and technological aspects that drive them. Healthcare and data is possibly as complex as it gets in all of these domains. This data map might be great – an atlas could be better.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

12 responses to “NHS Data – do we need a map or atlas?”

  1. Discover more Avatar

    Hi, just wanted to mention, I liked this post. It was helpful.

    Keep on posting!

    1. More details Avatar

      I adore how you break down complicated concepts into comprehensible notions. You are a fantastic guide.

      1. Denis Avatar

        I appreciate the freshness and creativity in your writing.

      2. Sheldon Avatar

        I’m always amazed by the thoroughness of research that goes into your blog posts.

    2. Reid Avatar

      Your post is a revolutionary piece; it challenged my perspective.

    3. Tianna Avatar

      Your blog feels like a source of wisdom and inspiration. Thank you for sharing it with us.

  2. Visit us Avatar

    I love how you analyze complex concepts into understandable and understandable parts.

    1. Evelyne Avatar

      Your prose paints colorful images, allowing readers to immediately immerse themselves in your captivating descriptions.

    2. Sydney Avatar

      You possess a remarkable talent for turning commonplace topics into intriguing and captivating pieces of content. Great job!

  3. Humberto Avatar

    I am constantly on the lookout for quality content and this is one of them.

  4. Jami Avatar

    Exceptionally written article! I feel like a more informed individual already.

  5. Get started Avatar

    It is in point of fact a great and useful piece of information. I’m glad that you just shared this
    useful information with us. Please keep us informed
    like this. Thank you for sharing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *